← Back to Item
Photomatch Evidence Record
Regular Season Game Milwaukee @ New Jersey
Deshawn Stevenson
·
New Jersey Nets
Mar 12, 2012
Excluded
Opponent:
Milwaukee Bucks
·
Regular Season Game
Reference Excluded
Negative correspondence establishes that the item visible in the examined reference material is not the same physical item as the examined item.
This conclusion applies to the documented reference material for this case. It does not, by itself, establish that the examined jersey was never worn in another game, event or undocumented context.
Game Information
Photomatch Record
Date
Mar 12, 2012
Opponent
Milwaukee Bucks
Status
Excluded
Conclusion
Reference Excluded
Event / Game
Regular Season Game
Comparison
1
Mesh-Hole Misalignment Along the “T” and “S” Wordmark Letters
The mesh-hole pattern adjacent to the inner right edge of the letter “T” and within the lower inner curve of the letter “S” was compared between the examined jersey and the reference photograph. As highlighted by the red markings, the visible mesh columns intersect and follow the twill borders at different positions. The number, spacing and relative alignment of the holes do not correspond in these localized areas. These inconsistencies constitute negative visual evidence and indicate that the examined jersey is not the same physical jersey shown in the reference photograph.
2
images
·
2
match points
Image A — Reference / In-Game
Detail view of the “TS” wordmark on DeShawn Stevenson’s white New Jersey Nets jersey
Image B — Item / Comparison
Detail view of the “TS” wordmark on DeShawn Stevenson’s white New Jersey Nets jersey.
Visual Characteristics
Match & Mismatch Points
2
documented points
Photomatch Overview
Documented Match & Mismatch Points
2
documented points
Forensic Documentation
Research Notes
Photomatch Summary
Assessment
The comparison identified two independent mismatches between the examined jersey and the jersey shown in the in-game photograph. The first occurs along the lower section of the final letter in the “NETS” wordmark, where the mesh-hole pattern does not align with the corresponding twill edge. The second occurs beside the right edge of the letter “T”: the in-game jersey displays a vertical mesh-hole row immediately adjacent to the twill border, whereas the examined jersey does not.
Because the placement of the lettering over the underlying mesh fabric is fixed during manufacture, these localized differences cannot reasonably be attributed solely to folds, perspective or image quality. The available photographic evidence therefore indicates that the examined jersey is not the same physical jersey worn by DeShawn Stevenson in the reference photograph. The result is classified as a photographic mismatch.
Methodology
Comparison Method
The examined jersey and the in-game reference photograph were compared through enlarged, side-by-side inspection of the “NETS” wordmark. The analysis focused on the spatial relationship between the fixed twill lettering and the underlying rows of mesh perforations.
Individual mesh-hole rows were traced relative to identifiable points along the letter borders, including the right side of the “T” and the lower contour of the final letter. Differences in camera angle, fabric tension, curvature, folds and image resolution were considered during the assessment. Only localized areas that remained sufficiently visible in both images were used.
The mesh rows intersect or approach the twill borders at different positions in the two images. As these discrepancies occur in multiple independent locations, they provide consistent negative evidence against the examined jersey being the same physical garment shown in the reference photograph.
Evidence Sources
Image Documentation
Reference
Detail view of the “TS” wordmark on DeShawn Stevenson’s white New Jersey Nets jersey
Source:
Source not documented
Jersey
Detail view of the “TS” wordmark on DeShawn Stevenson’s white New Jersey Nets jersey.
Source:
Source not documented
Record Context
Player
Deshawn Stevenson
Item Record
PMF-000031
Documented Match Points
2